yujiri.xyz

Argument

There Is No History of Philosophy

I hear people talk about things like "when Libertarianism started", and "Mercantilism ... spanned from the 16th century to the 18th century". If you talk about that, you're being stupid.

https://youtu.be/WxPOAl4sBUQ?t=300

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/mercantilism.asp

Philosophies are ideas. They have no time period; no one invents them. Ideas can have a first believer, but if the idea isn't a history-based religion or something dependent on technological prerequisites but a general philosophy, then almost for certain the first human believer was long before recorded history and there have been thousands in the world at any time since the beginning of recorded history. The first believer of a philosophy is irrelevant to any discussion of the philosophy anyway.

It's not necessarily useless to talk about the time period an idea was popular for, but that's not how the Investopedia article presents it. They say it "*was* a system ..." and that it "*spanned* from X to Y".